Kenbrell Thompkins scored on a beautiful backs-houlder throw from Tom Brady. (Jared Wickerham, Getty Images) Monday Afternoon Rewind: Patriots vs Eagles Rajon Rondo (Nathaniel S. Butler/NBAE/Getty Images) Celtics Should Continue Patient Approach to Rebuilding Process Connelly’s Top Ten: Red Sox vs. Paint Drying Al Pacino, Paul Pierce Photo: Paul Pierce with Al Pacino on Private Jet

Sox Strong Play for Felix Not Strong Enough

Felix Hernandez

2002

Cleveland trades Bartolo Colon to Montreal for Cliff Lee, Grady Sizemore and Brandon Phillips

2008

Baltimore trades Erik Bedard to Seattle for Adam Jones, Chris Tillman, George Sherrill and two other minor league pitchers

2009?

Seattle trades Felix Hernandez to Boston for pitchers Clay Buchholz, Daniel Bard, Michael Bowden, Nick Hagadone and OF Josh Reddick

Wait…you mean that didn’t happen?

Do you ever have those moments when you think you can do a better GM job that the current ones in the major leagues? Well when the Boston Globe reported that the Mariners turned down a huge offer from the Red Sox for 23-year-old ace Felix Hernandez, I had one of those moments.

It’s not often that a team throws five very good prospects in your face for an ace pitcher. Much like the Indians in 2002 or Orioles in 2008, the Mariners could have found themselves with a nice young core as a result of dealing their ace pitcher. Well, word broke out that the Red Sox gave Seattle a list of eight prospects, from which they could choose five. The list:

  • RHP Clay Buchholz
  • RHP Daniel Bard
  • RHP Justin Masterson
  • LHP Nick Hagadone
  • RHP Michael Bowden
  • LHP Felix Doubront
  • OF Josh Reddick
  • SS Yamaico Navarro

My first thought was that I found it interesting the Red Sox did not include Casey Kelley, Ryan Westmoreland or Lars Anderson in this list. It makes sense that the Red Sox are not willing to move Anderson unless they receive a first baseman in return, but the exclusion of the other two leads me to believe that they are pretty untouchable if the organization is not willing to part with them for a young stud pitcher.

My second thought was “really?!” The Mariners could not find five players that would suit their team needs for one player, albeit a great one. Personally, I would have chosen the five players above (Buchholz, Bard, Hagadone, Bowden and Reddick). This would have given the Mariners three very good starting pitcher prospects, one future closer and a very good outfield prospect who is currently ranked second in the Sox farm system according to SoxProspects.com.

Why did the Mariners turn it down?

There is only one reason why the Mariners would decline such a trade. They plan on re-signing Hernandez to a long-term deal that will keep him in a Mariners uniform for a long time. If this is not the case, I would have to question the Mariners’ front office because they are not built to contend before 2011 and if they let Hernandez hit free agency they may be looking at one draft pick in 2012 as the remainder of what could be the greatest pitcher of our generation.

There are a lot of things to like about Hernandez. He has posted a 51-40 record with a 3.61 ERA, 1.29 WHIP, and 734 strikeouts in 818 2/3 innings…and he’s only 23 years old. He is under contract for the next two seasons and for only around $3 million per year.

Will the Red Sox try to trade for King Felix again?

I expect the Red Sox to make a run at Hernandez in the off-season; much like the Mariners did with Erik Bedard before the 2008 season. However, the price will not be as high because there is something about the trade deadline that makes GM’s overpay for any advantage they can get for their playoff run.

It wouldn’t hurt the Red Sox to make a play for Hernandez either. They have the prospects to give and something tells me that my eyes could get used to watching Josh Beckett, Jon Lester and King Felix trot out to the mound three out of every five days.

Sox Rotation has Problems Down the Road

In all seriousness though, the Red Sox do have some questions with their rotation come next season. Dice-K’s arm troubles could be more serious than advertised, fan-favorite Tim Wakefield is more of a back-end rotation guy, Boston will probably not bring back Brad Penny or John Smoltz for another season, and Clay Buchholz continues to struggle in the majors. If Dice-K can return this season and show that he is recovered from his shoulder injury, I would not be surprised if the Red Sox offered him in a package of prospects for King Felix.

Only time will tell whether the Mariners missed out on a huge deal for Hernandez, but they better have plans to sign him long term or they may be looking at another Alex Rodriguez situation.

Tags: ,

Discussion

One comment for “Sox Strong Play for Felix Not Strong Enough”

  1. [...] They tried to bring him in at the trade deadline for five of their top eight prospects that included Buchholz, Daniel Bard, Justin Masterson, Nick Hagadone, Bowden, Doubront, Yamaico Navarro, and Josh Reddick. The Mariners declined the trade that also involved the Padres with Gonzalez winding up in Seattle. If they do pursue the deal again, then I am sure that the same names would probably be listed, except for Masterson, who of course is now in Cleveland. [...]

    Posted by Red Sox Need Big Bat this Offseason | Sports of Boston | November 3, 2009, 7:01 am

Post a comment