Connelly’s Top Ten: Less Than a Week to Opening Day! Red-Sox-Fans Why 2014 Should Make Red Sox Fans Smile Carol Vadnais Former Bruins Player Carol Vadnais Dies Red Sox Manager John Farrell (Source: Jared Wickerham/Getty Images North America) John Farrell’s Second Season Unlike his First

Ranking the AL East: Catchers

McCann should have quite the impact on the AL East (Maddie Meyer/Getty Images)

We’re inching ever closer to Opening Day as games have begun in Spring Training! As our ranking series goes on, this week focuses on catchers. The Yankees’ acquisition received a lot of love, but there are some other impact catchers in the AL East as well.

1. Brian McCann, New York Yankees: He has hit at least 20 home runs in sixth straight seasons. He is one of three catchers in history the others are Yogi Berra and Johnny Bench. McCann is an impact bat behind the plate and for a team that struggled scoring runs last year, his addition should help the Yankees. Expect the short porch in right field boost McCann’s power numbers making 30 home runs and outside possibility.

2. Matt Wieters, Baltimore Orioles: Matt Wieters has two All-Star appearances under his belt, as well as two Gold Gloves and yet it feels like he still has much improving to do. His defense is spectacular, but his bat has not caught up yet. Last year was his worst in the Majors as Wieters posted a career low .287 OBP, though he did surpass 20 home runs. Wieters is still only 27 years old and as catchers typically bloom late, this may be the year he puts it all together.

3. A.J. Pierzynski/David Ross, Boston Red Sox: This veteran duo (both 37) are expected to share duties behind the plate for Boston. Pierzynki is expected to get the bulk of the at-bats versus righthanders and Ross is expected to play around 60 games primarily against lefties. While this duo will not put up huge offensive numbers, they will bring a gutsy work ethic and solid defense behind the plate.

4. Ryan Hanigan, Tampa Bay Rays: Ryan Hanigan fits the Tampa Bay mold perfectly. He is a light-hitting catcher having never hit more than 6 home runs in a season, but he carries a career .359 OBP. In fact, excluding a 5-game stint in 2007, Hanigan has always walked more than he has struck out in a year, holding a career mark of 189 walks and 159 strikeouts. Another plus to Hanigan’s game is his ability to stop the run game, including a league leading 48% caught stealing in 2012.

5. Dioner Navarro, Toronto Blue Jays: Navarro had a bounce back season last year hitting a career high .300/.365/.492 with 13 home runs. Unfortunately, this seems to be more of a blip on a radar than Navarro becoming a solid catching option. The switch hitter has a career .251 average and struggles to get on base. Navarro is solid defensively so that is helpful, but do not expect much impact from him.

Brian Roach

1. Brian McCann, New York Yankees: McCann may have had some eye problems over the past two seasons, but still played over 100 games for the eighth straight season in 2013. Sure, he only hit .256, but he had 20 or more home runs for the sixth straight year. His 57 RBI may be due to the 102 games and 402 plate appearances may have reduced this number. With the Yankees offense rejuvenated with several new players, McCann should get opportunities to drive runs in. Plus, he is a stellar game caller and defender behind the plate.
2. Matt Wieters, Baltimore Orioles: The 27-year-old had a down year with a .235 average and a .287 OBP, but still played great defensively. The 22 homers and 79 RBI were nearly career-highs and he has remained healthy with 130 or more contests played each year since 2010. If he can improve his eye at the plate, then he will be the best catcher in division.
3. A.J. Pierzynski, Boston Red Sox: Pierzynski may not be the offensive stud at catcher he once was, but he can still get the job done on a regular basis for the Red Sox. The 27-year-old has a lot of experience that he can bring to train the catchers coming up in the farm system this spring training and will be a great addition the clubhouse. That being said, he no longer has a great eye at the plate with only 11 walks in 2013 with 134 games. The power in his bat will help some, but who knows if he can keep up the production he has the last couple of seasons. Davis Ross will likely play two or three times each week.
4. Dioner Navarro, Toronto Blue Jays: With less than 100 games played for the last four seasons, Navarro has mainly been used as a backup since his days with the Tampa Bay Rays. The 30-year-old will come back to the AL East ready to get back behind the dish on a more regular basis than previous seasons. Navarro has great defensive abilities, but is not much of a threat at the plate. Expect to see Josh Thole at least half the time.
5. Ryan Hanigan, Tampa Bay Rays: After seven seasons, with the Cincinnati Reds, the 33-year-old will try to break out with the Rays in 2014. In 2013, he played in 75 games with 222 at-bats, but showed little power with two homers while driving in 21 runs. The real strength for Hanigan is his ability to throw out runners and that will come in handy as the AL East can still steal bases even with Jacoby Ellsbury out of the picture. However, Hanigan value suffers greatly if you want him in fantasy.

Scott Siegler

1. Brian McCann, New York Yankees: The Yankees got themselves one of the top offensive catchers in the game. The only thing preventing me from being convinced that they have made a solid long term investment is his steady decline in at-bats over the past six seasons. However, many of his offensive statistics have remained consistent in spite of fewer at-bats so this could mean McCann is even more productive now than he was six seasons ago. He gets on base exceptionally well for a catcher and will definitely contribute a lot when he is on the field for the Yankees.

2. AJ Pierzynski, Boston Red Sox: This will be the final season that Pierzynski enters the season ahead of Wieters in my rankings. Both catchers had very comparable seasons in 2013, so AJ gets my vote of confidence because he has been doing it for so much longer. Unlike McCann, AJ doesn’t have any trouble staying on the field throughout the course of a season. The 16-year veteran hasn’t had fewer than 460 at-bats since 2002. While his numbers aren’t quite as impressive, they are all but guaranteed. While we haven’t seen Wieters full potential, I’d go with AJ at this season, and likely for the last time.

3. Matt Wieters, Baltimore Orioles: Wieters has a ton of pop and has proven he can get on base a whole lot more effectively than he did last season. However, the 27-year-old has struggled in the consistency department. In 2013, Wieters walked at his lowest rate since his rookie season and logged the second highest single season strikeout total of his career. Still, an area that he has been consistent is in his power numbers. The South Carolina native hit 22, 23, and 22 home runs, respectively, in each of his past 3 seasons and logged 28, 27, and 29, respectively, in the doubles category. He probably won’t hit .300 this season, but he has the potential to contribute in a big way none the less.

4. Ryan Hanigan, Tampa Bay Rays: There’s one thing that Hanigan has specialized in throughout his career and that is exactly the reason he is the opening day starter for the Rays. The guy can get on base. A career OBP of .359 speaks for itself. After spending the past seven seasons with the Reds, the sample size is convincing, However, there’s really not that much else that Hanigan is bringing to the table here. The most at-bats he’s ever had in a season is 317 and has never cracked more than six home runs in a season. The Rays may be challenged with depth issues at the catcher between Hanigan and an aging Jose Molina.

5. Dioner Navarro, Toronto Blue Jays:Navarro could have a fantastic season, but he hasn’t given me much evidence to believe that will be the case. Over the past four seasons, the Venezuela native has averaged less than 153 at-bats. However, he did see his most at-bats come in 2013, a season where he also clubbed a career high 13 home runs and got on base at a .365 clip. Navarro could be a dark horse for a big season, but another injury plagued flash in the pan is looking more likely at this point.

What are your rankings? Let us know in the comments below, and be sure to check out next week’s rankings on the outfield. Remember, we’re only 28 days away from Opening Day.

About Jamie Worthington - @Jam_Worth

Jamie is a regular contributor and editor for Sports of Boston, but has thoughts for all Boston areas sports for SoB. He loves that in sports everyone is allowed to have their own opinion and wants to hear yours! Follow him on twitter at: @Jam_Worth

Tags: , , , , ,

Discussion

No comments for “Ranking the AL East: Catchers”

Post a comment