Earlier this week Brad wrote an excellent article that addressed the recent Clay Buchholz trade rumors, in which he argued that the Red Sox should keep the mercurial starter. While Brad made a well-reasoned case, I would like to play devil’s advocate and outline a case for trading Buchholz, in an attempt to cash in while he is pitching well and his value on the open market may be inflated. I would like to start this outline by agreeing with Brad in that we need to look at what Buchholz actually is, rather than what the Red Sox say he can be.
Despite all of the hoopla about how great Buchholz’s stuff is and how good he can be, the reality is that in a good rotation he is no better than a number three starter. A mid-rotation starter is expected to be solid, if not average, performance-wise with the ability to go deep into a game and eat innings over the course of a season. Continue reading The Case For Trading Clay Buchholz »